Home / Emperors / Sixteen Kingdoms
The Last Four Rulers of Later Zhao
后赵最后四位帝王
Shi Shi (d. 349), Shi Zun (d. 349), Shi Jian (d. 350) and Shi Zhi (d. 351) · four rulers in twenty-three months
In the fourth month of 349 the emperor Shi Hu died at Ye, and within a day the government of the Zhao state had become a negotiation between an empress, a chancellor and the officers of the palace guard. The first man put on the throne after him held it for thirty-three days. The second held it for a hundred and eighty-three. The third held it for a hundred and three. The fourth held a title at Xiangguo for a little over a year and was killed by an officer he had sent against his enemy. None of the four was chosen by a rule, and none of them died in bed.
Four men on one throne in twenty-three months. None of them has the material for a separate life; together they have the material for a collapse. Each reign is unintelligible by itself: the promise that ruined Shi Zun was made to the man who marched in his van, the plot that destroyed Shi Jian was aimed at the man who had made him emperor, and the title Shi Zhi carried north to Xiangguo was the title the other three had already lost in the capital. One at a time they are four failures. In sequence they are one failure, repeated at a shortening interval, and the subject is not four men but a rule of succession coming apart while the office it served stayed standing.
1. Four Sons of One House
Shi Le founded the state in 319; Shi Hu, a kinsman raised in Shi Le's household, took the throne from Shi Le's son in 334 and held it for fifteen years. The four who follow were all sons of Shi Hu, and their names differ from one another by a syllable. Shi Shi was the youngest son, born to Lady Liu, the last woman Shi Hu made empress. Shi Zun was the ninth son, Prince of Pengcheng, holding Henei when his father died. Shi Jian was the third son, Prince of Yiyang. Shi Zhi, Prince of Xinxing, held Xiangguo, the old capital in the hills north of Ye.
Historians call the state the Later Zhao so as not to confuse it with the older Zhao of the Warring States or with Liu Yuan's Han Zhao; the court called itself simply Zhao. The distinction matters, because a state that calls itself Zhao claims the whole of the old Zhao territory, and these four spent their reigns claiming it while holding less and less of it.
The house had broken its own rule once already, and that precedent is the first fact of the story. In 334 Shi Hu took the throne from Shi Le's son Shi Hong, deposed and killed him. A house that has done that once has no rule left to invoke; it has a habit, which is that the throne goes to the man who can hold Ye. What changed in 349 was the speed. Shi Hu had needed a year and an army. His sons needed a palace and a guard.
Shi Hu died at Ye in the fourth month of 349, in the last year of the era Tai Ning. The memoir of his reign runs to two chapters; the four reigns that follow occupy the last pages of the second, before the memoir of Ran Min. The Tang compilers who made the Book of Jin in 648 filed the collapse as an appendix to the father's life.
2. The Regency and the Gate
Shi Hu made Shi Shi his heir in the last year of his life, in the inner apartments rather than at court. His mother, Lady Liu, was a daughter of Liu Yao, the last Han Zhao emperor, taken into Shi Hu's household when her father's state fell. The memoir says Shi Hu favoured her, and that she and the palace official Zhang Chai pressed her son's claims. The strongest candidate at court was Shi Bin, Prince of Yan, an adult son who was chancellor and director of the secretariat. Zhang Chai, expecting to govern in the heir's name, forged Shi Hu's order and had Shi Bin killed while the old emperor was dying.
That is the founding act of the succession: not a designation but a forgery, committed by the man who was to be regent against the one son who could govern. The court that came out of the death chamber had Lady Liu as empress dowager, Zhang Chai as chancellor, and Shi Shi as emperor. The Jie guard of Ye, the household's old soldiers, were the only troops in the capital, and their loyalty was to the family, not the regency.
Shi Zun was at Henei with an army. He was returning from the western campaign with the generals who had put down Liang Du's revolt, among them Yao Yizhong, Fu Hong and Shi Min, Shi Hu's adopted grandson, the future Ran Min. They met him at Li City and told him the throne was his if he marched. The memoir has them say the late emperor had intended him and Zhang Chai had misled him; spoken or not, the argument worked.
He marched with ninety thousand men, the memoir says, and Shi Min in the van. Zhang Chai ordered the garrison out to meet him, and the garrison refused. The old Jie soldiers, the memoir says, stood on the wall and said the Son of Heaven's son had come to mourn his father; they would go out to welcome him, and would not hold the city for Zhang Chai. They climbed over the wall in daylight. A gate officer named Zhang Li opened the gate with two thousand of the palace cavalry. Zhang Chai was taken at the Anyang pavilion and executed in the Ping Le market with his kin to the third degree. Shi Zun entered by the Fengyang Gate, wept in the Hall of Supreme Martiality, and only then took the throne.
Lady Liu was made to issue an edict declaring that the throne had come to her son by the late emperor's private favour rather than by any right, and that the enterprise was too heavy for him. The phrase is the regime's own admission that no rule had been applied. Shi Shi was made Prince of Qiao with a fief of ten thousand households and the promise of treatment as a guest, not a subject. He and his mother were killed soon afterwards. He had reigned thirty-three days.
3. The Promise
The memoir begins Shi Zun's reign with a fire in the palace halls and blood raining over Ye. Setting the portents aside, he held the capital, the title and the commander of the army, and the last was the only one that mattered.
He took the imperial title, made his mother Empress Dowager Zheng, his wife empress, and named as heir Shi Yan, son of the murdered Shi Bin. Shi Zun had no son of his own, and by adopting the son of the man Zhang Chai had killed he could claim to repair the injustice of the accession; in the same act he refused the claim of the man who had put him on the throne.
The refusal was the promise. At Li City, before the march, he had told Shi Min that if the enterprise succeeded he would make him heir. The memoir's sentence is short: work hard, and when it is done you shall be heir. Shi Min had fought in the van on the strength of it. When the heirship went to Shi Yan he was, in the memoir's phrase, greatly disappointed. He thought his service greater than any man's and expected to direct the government; Shi Zun, fearing him, gave him no civil office, only the army.
Shi Min was made commander of all forces in the capital and used the post to build a following in the palace. He enrolled the inner-court guards and the strong men of the former eastern palace, more than ten thousand by the memoir's count, as extra generals and frontier marquises, and made them his clients. Shi Zun graded their names for good and ill, then took advice from Meng Zhun and Wang Luan and began to strip Shi Min of his commands; their advice was to kill him.
The decision was taken in front of his mother. Shi Zun summoned his brothers, Shi Jian among them, and put the question; all said kill him. The old woman refused. Without Jinu, she said, using the adopted grandson's childhood name, would we be here today? He is a little arrogant; do not kill him out of hand. Shi Jian left the hall and sent the eunuch Yang Huan to warn him. Within days Shi Min had drawn Li Nong and the right guard Wang Ji into a plot to depose the emperor.
The arrest was made by thirty armoured men. Shi Zun was in the Ruyi Belvedere, playing a board game with a woman, when Su Hai and Zhou Cheng came in. He asked who the rebels were. Zhou Cheng said the Prince of Yiyang, Shi Jian, was to be installed. The memoir has Shi Zun answer that if he, the emperor, could be treated so, how long would they last with Shi Jian? He was killed in the Kunhua Hall with his mother, his crown prince, and the officials who had advised him. He had reigned a hundred and eighty-three days.
4. The Emperor in the Belvedere
Shi Jian was in the room when the decision to kill Shi Min was taken, and he left it and sent the warning. He was made emperor by the man he had warned, and he spent his hundred and three days trying to kill him.
His first act was to reward the men who had made him: Shi Min became grand general and Prince of Wude, Li Nong grand marshal, both directors of the secretariat. The man who would abolish the dynasty was, for a season, a prince of the house he was about to destroy.
Within the month he tried to remove him. He sent Shi Bao, Prince of Leping, the palace secretary Li Song and a palace general Zhang Cai to attack Shi Min and Li Nong at the Kunhua Hall at night. The attack failed; the palace was thrown into confusion. The emperor then did the thing that defines his reign: he pretended not to have known, had Li Song and Zhang Cai beheaded at the western gate, and killed Shi Bao as well. He gave up his own assassins to prove his innocence to the man they had been sent to kill.
Shi Zhi at Xiangguo joined the Qiang and Di chiefs and proclaimed against Shi Min and Li Nong. The memoir says Shi Jian sent Shi Kun against his brother Shi Zhi with seventy thousand men; it was the last army Ye sent out on its own.
The end came from the guard. Sun Fudu and Liu Zhu, two officers of the Jie guard, gathered three thousand men in the Hu quarter, the memoir says, and planned to attack Shi Min. Sun Fudu took thirty men to the emperor's terrace, cut the gallery, and told him Li Nong had rebelled and he was deploying the guards. Shi Jian answered that he was a meritorious subject, should do his utmost, and would be watched from the terrace and rewarded.
The attack failed. Sun Fudu and his men fell back to the Fengyang Gate. Shi Min and Li Nong came in through the Jinming Gate with a few thousand men. Shi Jian, fearing Shi Min would kill him, sent for the two, opened the gate, and said Sun Fudu had rebelled and should be put down at once. They put him down, and the memoir says the dead lay from the Fengyang Gate to the Kunhua Hall.
What Shi Min did to the Hu of the capital belongs to his own account; neither the wording of the proscription nor its figures is repeated here. What belongs here is what it did to the office. The emperor was taken to the Yulong Belvedere and guarded by several thousand men, his food hoisted up on a rope; the government of Ye was conducted in Shi Min's name; the guard that had tried to save the throne was destroyed. A throne guarded by the man who attacked it is no longer a government. It is a room with a seal in it.
At the turn of the year 350 Shi Min took the last step short of deposition. The state was renamed Wei, a different state from the one he would found weeks later, though English gives both the same name. The imperial surname was changed by decree from Shi to Li, and the era name was changed to Qing Long. It was justified by a prophecy that the Zhao would be succeeded by a Li. For some weeks the emperor of Zhao was the emperor of a state called Wei and the head of a house called Li, both chosen by his general.
A eunuch carried a letter from the emperor to a commander outside the city, asking him to attack while Shi Min was away; the eunuch took it to Shi Min. Shi Min returned, deposed him, had him killed, and killed thirty-eight of Shi Hu's grandsons, the memoir says. The reign had lasted a hundred and three days.
5. The King at Xiangguo
Xiangguo was the old capital, the city from which the dynasty had ruled before the move to Ye. When Ye fell to Shi Min, the officials who would not serve him went north: the grand preceptor Zhao Lu, the grand commandant Zhang Ju, Shi Yue and Shi Ning, and more than ten thousand persons, the memoir says. A court assembled in the old capital because it could no longer assemble in the new one.
Shi Zhi took the imperial title in the third month of 350 and changed the era to Yong Ning. He was the only one of the four to begin a calendar of his own. He made Shi Kun chancellor and bought the Qiang and Di chiefs with offices, princely titles and cavalry commands. These were not gifts from strength: the Qiang, the Di and the Murong had the cavalry he lacked, and he was paying them with titles to land he did not hold.
The war went badly, then briefly well. Shi Kun attacked Ye with a large army and was beaten by a much smaller force; Shi Zhi moved south to Handan and was beaten there. In the winter Shi Min besieged Xiangguo for more than a hundred days. The city held; the countryside did not. Shi Zhi then did the thing that shows what the throne had become. He gave up the imperial title, called himself King of Zhao, and sent to the Murong and to Yao Yizhong for cavalry.
The relief came in the spring of 351. Yao's son, a Murong brother and Shi Kun's remnant broke the siege and destroyed the army outside the walls. The figures for the dead belong to the account of the man who lost them. The last emperor of Zhao had traded his title for a relief army, and the men who saved him were not his subjects and did not become them. No source says he took the title back.
He sent Liu Xian with some seventy thousand men after the retreating army; Liu Xian was beaten outside Ye. Liu Xian then sent a secret offer to Shi Min: he would kill his own emperor and be rewarded for it. In the fourth month of 351 he came back to Xiangguo, killed Shi Zhi, the chancellor Shi Bing and the grand preceptor Zhao Lu, and sent the head south. Shi Min burned it in the street. The Later Zhao, which had held the north for thirty-two years, ended in the city where it had begun, in a bargain struck by an officer of its own army.
6. Three Faults in a Rule
The twenty-three months can be told as a chain of betrayals, and most accounts do. The useful question is why the same betrayal could be performed four times with the same materials. The answer has three parts, each built into the Zhao state before 349.
The first is the father's choice. Shi Hu had no rule of succession; he had a preference, and he exercised it from his deathbed. He had already killed two grown sons, one in 337 and one in 348, and the court had learned to watch the inner apartments rather than the lineage. When he chose the son of Lady Liu he passed over the adult princes who held the garrisons, and he left the government to a chancellor who had everything to gain from a minority. Such a designation does not settle a succession; it invites the next strongest man to reopen it, and supplies him with the argument. The edict that deposed Shi Shi said in its own words that the throne had been given by private favour.
The second is the regent's pen. Zhang Chai's first act was to forge the old emperor's order and kill Shi Bin, the one adult son who could have governed. That is not a failure of the succession; it is a succession conducted by forgery, and it set the pattern. Every later transfer was wrapped in someone else's authority: Lady Liu's edict for Shi Zun, the emperor's seal for Shi Min's decrees, and at last the decree that renamed the imperial house. The chancellery, the seals and the scribes worked to the end. Nothing they produced was final.
The third is the adopted grandson. Shi Hu's household had absorbed the sons of defeated enemies for two generations. Ran Min's father was taken at twelve and given to Shi Hu to raise, and Ran Min was raised as a grandson of the house. Adoption made him intimate; it did not make him an heir. He was inside the family's rooms and outside its order, and he commanded the troops in the capital. In a normal succession such a man is a servant. In a succession with no rule he is the only person who can decide, and a man who can decide four times will eventually decide for himself.
Under the three is a fourth fact, which is not a fault but a structure. The Zhao army was a coalition of household troops: a Jie core settled around Ye and enrolled from father to son, six contingents of other peoples with their own commanders, and the garrison farms. Such an army wins battles and cannot be commanded from a throne. Its officers had followings, and the followings had needs. Ran Min built his by enrolling the palace guard and giving them ranks and women; Shi Zhi built his by handing out provinces to Yao and Fu. The only asset the throne held in its own right was Ye: the arsenals, the granaries, the stables, and the households of the soldiers. Whoever held Ye held the throne. Whoever held the throne without Ye held a title.
That is why the geography of the two years is so simple. Three of the four ruled in Ye and the fourth at Xiangguo. The three in Ye could make and unmake one another because they stood next to the same stores. The one at Xiangguo could not march south with an army of his own, because he had a title, a city and no treasury; he had to buy cavalry, and the price of cavalry was the title. The durations repeat it: thirty-three days, a hundred and eighty-three, a hundred and three. The first reign ended when a brother marched; the second when a general was refused; the third when a guard was disowned. Each time the instrument stood closer to the throne.
The throne did not fall in 349. It was emptied, four times, and it stayed standing because it was useful. Shi Min needed its seal to rename the state. Shi Zhi needed its name to buy a relief army. Neither could rule with it. Both could still use it, and that is the difference between a government and an office that everyone could use and no one could hold.
7. The Record of Twenty-Three Months
The disproportion is the first fact of the record. The Book of Jin, compiled in 648 from the state histories of the northern courts, gives Shi Hu two chapters; it gives the four men who followed him, and Ran Min who ended them, the last pages of the second. Their reigns are entered in the manner of a register, with the number of days each man held the throne, and those numbers are the most exact thing in the account.
Part of the reason is archival. A reign of thirty-three days does not generate the paperwork of fifteen years: no full series of edicts, no census, no tomb, no stele, no calendar of audiences. Part is destruction. Ye was occupied by Shi Min's troops in 350 and by the Yan in 352; Xiangguo was burned in 352. The Zhao state history was kept by officials who had to finish it under the men who had destroyed their patrons, or not finish it at all. Part is the victors. The northern archive reached the Tang through the Yan and the Northern Wei, both enemies of the Shi.
The Comprehensive Mirror of 1084 supplies the month-by-month order the Book of Jin lacks; it is a secondary work, useful for sequence, not a witness in its own right. Cui Hong's Spring and Autumn of the Sixteen States is a sixth-century compilation that disappeared in the Northern Song. What circulates as a hundred-chapter text is a Ming reconstruction, the work of Tu Qiaosun and Xiang Linzhi, assembled out of the Book of Wei, the Book of Jin and the Mirror, and it cannot be cited as a primary source. Where the three agree, they descend from the same few pages.
The speeches are the same kind of evidence. The memoir has Shi Zun ask who the rebels were, has Zhou Cheng name the next emperor, and has the condemned man predict his successor's short reign; it has the empress dowager call Ran Min by his childhood name and refuse to kill him. These are scenes a court history composes when it knows the ending. They may be true, but their truth is not the kind a reader can check, which is why this account attributes them to the memoir whenever it repeats them.
What remains is a sequence of administrative facts, and they are enough. Four men held the throne. None succeeded by a rule; each was installed by a courtier, a general or himself, and each was removed by a servant or a kinsman. The provinces were promised to generals who kept them. The last man gave up the title to buy cavalry and was killed by the officer he had sent to pursue his enemy. A state can survive a bad ruler. It cannot survive an office that no one can hold, and the record of these twenty-three months is thin because there was almost nothing left for a court annalist to write about except the days.
The last entry is a head sent south and burned in the street. The annalist records the days, the killings and the burning, and then begins the memoir of the man who did the burning.