Home / Emperors / Sixteen Kingdoms
Liu Xi of Han Zhao
汉赵刘熙
Liu Xi, ? – 329 · crown prince who held Han Zhao after his father's capture, never enthroned
A title can name a seat that no longer exists. In 319, after his father had made Chang'an the capital again, the son of Yang Xianrong was named crown prince of Han Zhao. The act belonged to a whole settlement: the mother was made empress, the altars were put in order, and six other sons were given principalities — Changle, Taiyuan, Huainan, Qi, Lu and Chu. A crown prince is a person designated for a chair that is not yet empty, and the designation carries an expectation of transfer. In 328 the chair emptied while the designation stayed. The father was taken prisoner in the east, and the son went on being called the heir to a throne on which no one could sit. He never sat on it. The word survived; the office behind it did not.
He also never did anything that the sources call a decision. At the council in Chang'an he was present, and the account gives him no words. When the one minister who argued for holding the city was killed, the order came from his elder brother. When the court abandoned Chang'an, it followed that brother. When an army went back to recover the city, the brother led it and the enemy chose the ground. Liu Xi's part in these events was to be named in them as the heir. What follows is about what an inheritance of a name is worth when there is no procedure for turning it into power. He kept the name to the end and died still the crown prince.
1. A Title Without a Seat
The settlement of 319 was a distribution of names. Liu Yao had lost Pingyang, the old capital in the Fen valley, and had moved the court into the palaces of Chang'an. He had made Yang Xianrong, once the empress of the Jin dynasty that the Liu house had destroyed, his own empress. Their son was made crown prince. The other sons received commanderies in a single list, and the list matters less for the individual names than for what it shows: the ruler was providing for his sons by dividing the map among them, and the heir was one provision among several. An heir's title in such a system is not an office with duties. It is a claim about the future, made by a father who is still alive to make it.
The claim worked only while the father was there to stand behind it. Han Zhao had never produced a rule for the transfer of power. Its first succession had been settled by seven days of violence, its second by a palace murder, and the throne had passed to the man who could reach the gate with soldiers. The title of crown prince named the person whom the reigning ruler favoured; it did not name the person whom the army would obey. These had not been the same man in 310, and they were not plainly the same man now. Liu Xi had the mother who had been empress of two courts and the formal designation of the heir. His elder brother Liu Yin, a son of Liu Yao's first wife who had been lost for years among the Heini Yuju and had returned a grown man, had the soldiers. The sources set the two facts side by side and leave the tension unresolved.
That was the arrangement of 319, and it held for nine years because nothing happened to test it. Yang Xianrong died in 322; after that no one at court pressed the heir's claim, but the title itself was not withdrawn. There is a proposal in the chronology to give the heir's place to the elder brother, stopped by the remonstrance of the ministers; it belongs to the account of the father, and it is not retold here. What matters is that the son grew up holding a designation that everyone could see and no mechanism could enforce. While the father lived, this was a flaw hidden inside a working government: the court issued orders and the heir was addressed by his title at the ceremonies that required one.
In 328 the test came from outside. The father campaigned in the east and was taken prisoner, and the government at Chang'an received the news without the man who had made it work. Everything that the title had pointed toward now depended on a transfer that had never been defined. Who was to issue commands? Who was to command the army that had followed the father? The crown prince was the obvious answer only if one assumed that a name carries power with it. In Han Zhao it did not. The name carried a claim, and the claim had to be made good by somebody else.
The chair had been empty since 328, and Liu Xi continued to be named for it. This is the whole reason his brief tenure has a place in the record at all. He was not a ruler who lost a throne he had held. He was the heir whose throne vanished while he was still being called its heir, and who had no way of turning the word into anything more than a word.
2. The Message From Xiangguo
The first communication from the captive father did not reach Chang'an as a command to submit. To the heir it came as the opposite. Shi Le, who held Liu Yao, required him to write to his son and demand that Chang'an surrender. The account in the Book of Jin has the prisoner write instead that the son should govern together with the senior ministers, preserve the altars and the state, and not alter his purpose on account of what had happened to his father. The wording is the court historian's, and it is not reproduced here. The substance is what matters: the letter told the heir not to obey the man who had dictated it.
For Liu Xi the message carried a paradox he could not resolve. The father was alive, so the letter had the authority of the reigning ruler; but the father was a prisoner, so he could no longer issue an order that any commander was bound to obey. The document was an order that denied its own source. It asked the son to continue a government whose head was in captivity, and it named as the instrument of that government the ministers who had been serving at Chang'an. The record gives no answer from Liu Xi, no summons, no council convoked in the name of the letter. It gives the letter and then the next event.
Shi Le was displeased by the answer and had Liu Yao killed. That is all the account says of the end of the father, and it is enough for the son's situation. The man who could have converted the heir's title into a working authority was now dead at the enemy's capital, and the only instruction he had left directed his son to hold firm without telling him how. Liu Xi possessed a name, a letter, and a court that still used the forms of government, while the armies belonged to other men.
There is a further difficulty in the provenance. Xiangguo was Shi Le's seat, the centre of the rival state on the plain. Any document that came from there had passed through enemy hands, even when the hand that wrote it was the father's. The heir could not treat the letter as a private family message, nor could he treat it as a forged order, because it was neither in any simple sense. It was the last act of a ruler who still had a title and no longer had a state to govern. For the son who received it, it was a command to keep a position that no one had defined and that nothing now supported.
The letter also fixed the terms on which the heir would act. He was to preserve the state with the ministers. That phrase assumed a body of men who would govern in his name and a state that could be preserved. Within weeks the assumption was tested at a council in Chang'an, and the test showed how little either term meant when the father was gone.
3. The Argument at Chang'an
The council met in the first month of 329. Liu Xi sat with Liu Yin and Liu Xian and others, and the question before them was whether Chang'an could be held. The proposal was to abandon the city and withdraw west into Qinzhou, to the walled town of Shanggui on the upper Wei. The argument for retreat was the obvious one: the ruler who had given the court its coherence was dead, the eastern army had destroyed the field force, and the capital stood in a valley that could no longer feed it.
Hu Xun, a minister of the court, argued against the move. The record puts these words in his mouth: Though our lord is gone, the state is still intact, the soldiers and officers are of one mind and none has deserted; let us join our strength and hold the defiles — there will be time to leave later. This is the one passage preserved as direct speech in this account of the heir, and it is given as the record's wording rather than as a transcript. Its reasoning is precise. Hu Xun did not deny that the father had died or that the state was weak. He denied the premise that weakness required flight. The soldiers had not mutinied, the registers still answered, and the passes to the west of the city could be held. Flight was an option, he said, but it was an option that remained open only while men believed it was still possible to stay.
The decision went the other way. Liu Yin would not accept the argument and was angered by what he took as Hu Xun's discouragement of the assembled men. He had Hu Xun beheaded. Here the record is explicit about who acted: the elder brother gave the order, and the heir, whose name heads the list of those present, is given no line of his own. Whether he agreed or objected cannot be recovered, and it is not a matter of filling a silence with a guess. What can be said is that the only recorded speech in the council was the one that was rejected, and the only recorded decision was the one the brother made.
The court then left Chang'an for Shanggui. Liu Hou and Liu Ce abandoned the garrisons they held and went with it. The source says that Guanzhong fell into disorder, and the disorder is easier to explain than the speech. A government that moves out of its capital in the middle of a council loses the men who had been holding its gates, and a province whose commanders are leaving with the court has no reason to keep its own watch. The abandonment was not a retreat planned and executed by a single command. It was a flight that the brother ordered and that the officers turned into a general movement.
Two generals, Jiang Ying and Xin Shu, did not go. They held Chang'an with a force that the record numbers in the hundreds of thousands — a round figure for a crowd, not a tally — and sent envoys to Shi Le offering to receive his authority. Shi Le responded by sending Shi Sheng with the troops he had stationed at Luoyang. The city that Liu Xi had been advised to hold was therefore handed to the enemy by the men left inside it. The heir arrived at Shanggui with a court that had lost its capital, and the letter from his father, urging him to preserve the state with his ministers, had been answered by the destruction of the one man who had argued that the state was worth preserving.
4. The Road Back
In the eighth month of 329 the brother led the court's remaining strength back toward Chang'an. Liu Yin and Liu Zun took several tens of thousands of men, a figure the record gives in round terms, from Shanggui against Shi Sheng, who held the city for Shi Le. The column moved down from the upper Wei. What followed shows what the name of the ruling house could still do when a member of it appeared in person.
The commanderies of Longdong, Wudu, Anding, Xinping, Beidi, Fufeng and Shiping rose. The record says that both the Rong and the Xia populations took up arms in response to Liu Yin. This is the clearest statement in the whole account of where loyalty lay. The men who rose did so for the brother who had come back at the head of an army, not for the heir who sat at Shanggui with the title. Liu Yin was a prince of the blood and a commander who had fought; he carried the claim of the house in a form that people could follow. The crown prince carried the same claim in a form that required someone else to act on it. The rising was therefore both a sign of strength and a sign of where the strength had moved.
Liu Yin halted at Zhongqiao and did not take Chang'an by assault. Shi Sheng held the city and refused to come out. The camp at Zhongqiao was a repetition of the problem that had ended the father: an army sitting in front of walls it could not enter, on ground it had chosen but could not force. Shi Le did not leave the decision to his general in the city. He sent his nephew Shi Hu, whom the record also calls Shi Jilong, with twenty thousand cavalry, a figure given in the account as the size of the relief force. Shi Hu met Liu Yin at Yiqu. The brother's army was defeated there, and the account puts the dead above five thousand, a number that belongs to the account rather than to a verified tally.
Liu Yin fell back to Shanggui, and Shi Hu pursued him. The account says that the pursuit continued with the dead lying along the road for a thousand li. This is the language of a victory narrative, and it describes a rout rather than a measurement. What it marks is the end of the field force that had made the court's position at Shanggui defensible. The brother had made the decision to return, he had made the decision to camp at Zhongqiao, and he made the decision to withdraw. Shi Hu made the decision to give battle at Yiqu and the decision to press the retreat. Between them they settled the fate of the court. Liu Xi is named at none of these points, because the record does not place him at any of them.
Shanggui could not be held once the army had broken. The town was a refuge chosen in the first month of the year precisely because it lay beyond the passes, and its safety had always depended on the men who could be assembled in front of it. Those men had been defeated at Yiqu and scattered on the road back. The court was in a walled place with no field force, and the force that had brought it there was now destroying itself outside the walls. The last act of the war belonged to the enemy and to the brother. The heir had only his title left, and it was about to be recorded in the verb of the man who took the city.
5. Still the Heir
Shanggui fell. The account says that the town collapsed and that the victors seized the man they call the pseudo-crown-prince Xi, along with Liu Yin, Prince of Nanyang, and others, and put them all to death. The word pseudo is the language of the court that took the city, and it is worth noting without adopting it. It is a way of saying that the title was false. For the government that had conferred the title in 319, it was not false at all; it was the only title the state had ever given him, and no other had been added to it.
He was killed still holding it. Liu Xi never took the throne, never proclaimed an era, and never issued an edict in his own name. No posthumous title was given to him by his own state, because there was no state left to give one, and none by the state that killed him, because a pseudo-crown-prince is not a person whom a victor needs to name. The record gives him the designation he had been given as a boy and then stops. He is the last holder of the heir's title in the Han line, and not the last of its rulers, because he was never one of them.
What belongs to Liu Xi is narrower. In the first month of 329 he sat in a council and heard a man argue that the state was still whole. In the eighth month he was at Shanggui while his brother led an army out and the enemy chose the field. Between those months he had been addressed as the heir to a seat that had been empty since 328.
At the fall of Shanggui he was still what he had been made in 319: the crown prince of a state that no longer existed, holding a name that no process had ever turned into power. The decisions that ended him were made by his brother, by the commanders his father had left, and by the enemy. He had none of them to make.