Great Wall Information

Home / Emperors / Sixteen Kingdoms

Emperor Ai of Cheng-Han

成汉哀帝

Li Ban, ? – 334 · ruler of Cheng-Han

Li Xiong died in the sixth month of 334 and was buried only in the winter. In the months between, his state was ruled by his nephew Li Ban, who had been named heir ten years earlier and who spent his reign in the hall where the coffin stood. He issued no edict, fought no campaign, and left the government to the men his uncle had chosen. On a night in the tenth month, while he was keeping the vigil, his cousin Li Yue entered the hall and killed him.
Four months is not enough time to govern, and Li Ban did not try. That is what makes him hard to write about, and it is also why he repays the attempt. A reign with no policy and no battle is a section through a structure: it shows what the throne rested on, and what happened when the man sitting on it declined to use it. The record gives him a warning, a refusal and a death. Almost everything else is inference, and this account keeps to the order in which the record gives them.

1. The Fourth Son of Li Dang

Li Ban was Li Dang's fourth son, and Li Dang was Li Xiong's elder brother. Li Dang had been the man the family expected to lead it; he was killed in the fighting in 303, a month after his father Li Te. The house never stopped saying that the state had been built on his death, and Li Ban was raised in his uncle's household from childhood, one of the sons of the man who had not lived to inherit.
In 324 Li Xiong named him heir. He had more than ten sons of his own, and the ministers wanted one of them; Li Xiong answered that the enterprise had been his father's, that the elder brother's line had the better claim, and that was the whole of the argument. Li Ban had been schooled as a scholar. His teachers were He Dian and Li Zhao; he kept company with men of letters, and was consulted on great matters before he was given any office. The one policy attached to his name is a memorandum he wrote as heir: the great families were holding unused land while poor men had nowhere to plant, and the surplus ought to go to those who would farm it. Li Xiong accepted it; the record does not show that it was ever applied.
His public career was thin. He held an acting general's title and was put in charge of the garrison farm at Jinshou, on the northern road, where soldiers grew grain. It was useful work and it was not command. He had no following of his own, no clients, no provincial base and no troops who answered to him rather than to the state. In a house where the men who mattered raised soldiers, the heir had a reputation and a desk.
Li Xiong died. Li Ban took the throne in the same month and kept the era name Yuheng, so that the year of his accession was still the twenty-fourth of his uncle's reign. He confirmed three men in office: Li Shou, his father's cousin, as supervisor of the secretariat; He Dian as minister over the masses; Wang Gui as director of the secretariat. Then he went into mourning and took no part in government. The official chapter says it in a single clause: he stayed in the palace and performed the rites, and was involved in nothing. The administration ran without him, through men who had run it under his uncle.
That was correct conduct and a political mistake, and the two cannot be separated. A court in mourning is supposed to be quiet. But this court was not an office with a queue of business; it was a coalition of commanders who had been held together by one old man. The old man was dead. The heir's remaining asset was the coffin, and he spent his days beside it.

2. The Ninth Month

Li Yue was a son of Li Xiong and a general of chariots and cavalry, and he was stationed at Jiangyang, downriver from Chengdu, with troops. In the ninth month he came up to mourn his father. He did not accept Li Ban. His objection was not to Li Ban's character or his policy; it was that Li Ban was not a son of Li Xiong. The official chapter puts it plainly: he considered that Li Ban had not been born of Li Xiong, and his heart was not at peace.
Li Qi was in the capital. He was Li Xiong's fourth son, and therefore Li Ban's cousin: a general with a reputation for cleverness and generosity. When the old man had once ordered his sons to raise followers, the others had found hundreds and Li Qi had found more than a thousand. The two brothers talked.
Li Wu, Li Ban's younger brother, saw it coming. He was general of the north and governor of Liang, stationed at Fu, and he had come up for the funeral. He proposed a separation: send Li Yue back to Jiangyang, and give Li Qi the governorship of Liang with headquarters at Jiameng, so that the two men would be hundreds of li apart and neither would be in the palace. It was the obvious move, and it was the move a man with a following would have made.
Li Ban refused. His reason was that his uncle was not yet buried, and he would not send the dead man's sons away from the funeral. He also sent Li Wu back to Fu, which left him in Chengdu with no troops of his own and no kinsman who commanded any. The Comprehensive Mirror says he treated the two brothers with an open heart; the official chapter says the same: there was not a trace of suspicion in him.
There was an omen. Two bands of white vapor stretched across the sky. The director of astronomy, Han Bao, reported that the signs in the palace pointed to secret arms, and that the danger lay among kin. Li Ban did not understand.
The story is usually read as a portrait of a good man too trusting for politics, and there is truth in it. But the refusal was not only softness. It was a claim about what a funeral was for. Li Ban was saying that the mourning of Li Xiong took precedence over the quarrel among Li Xiong's sons, and that a man who could not keep faith with a funeral could not ask anyone to keep faith with him. That is a defensible position. It is not one that can be held without troops.

3. The Night Vigil

In the tenth month, on the night Li Ban was keeping vigil, Li Yue came into the hall and killed him beside the coffin. He killed Li Du as well, Li Ban's second elder brother, who commanded the palace guard. The local history says the killing took place at the mourning station; the official chapter says the funeral hall. The difference is one word, and neither changes the scene.
The rest was paperwork. Li Yue and Li Qi produced an order in the name of the empress dowager, Li Xiong's widow Lady Ren, which set out Li Ban's crimes and deposed him. The next day Li Qi took the throne. Li Xiong was buried at Andu that winter. The old man had lain in state through the whole of his nephew's reign, and he was buried by the son who had ended it.
Li Shou, who held the regency and the southern army, did nothing. Li Wu was at Fu, too far away; when the news reached him he fled east and entered the service of Jin. The officials of the court presented themselves to Li Qi. The record names no officer who died for Li Ban, and no guard who came to his defence. The palace guard had been commanded by Li Du, and Li Du was dead.
The charge against Li Ban was that he was not Li Xiong's son. That was true, and it was also the ground on which he had been made heir. Li Xiong had reasoned from the elder line: the enterprise was Li Dang's by right, and Li Dang's son should have it. His sons reasoned from the direct line: the enterprise was their father's, and a nephew is not a son. Both arguments were intelligible. Neither could refute the other, because they were not arguments about the same thing. One was about a debt and the other about blood, and the house had never decided which came first.
The killing was followed by a clearing of the ground. Li Ban's two sons, Li You and Li Yong, were killed in the years that followed. Li Wu died in Jin service in 347, the year the state fell. Of the five brothers, the local history says that all died by the sword and that four left no descendants.

4. The Names He Was Given

Li Qi gave him a posthumous name, and the name was an accusation: the Violent Heir. Not an emperor's name; a dead prince's. The word means the heir who turned against his house, and it was given by the man who had killed him in the hall where Li Xiong lay. He had held the throne for four months, which the annals count as a year because it began and ended inside one. He had done nothing, and he was buried under the name of the crime that had been committed against him.
Four years later, in 338, Li Shou came down from Fu with his army, took Chengdu and deposed Li Qi, who was made a duke and killed soon after. Li Shou then gave Li Ban the posthumous name Emperor Ai. Ai is the name for the ruler who was kind and did not last. It belongs to the small group of posthumous words that describe a life rather than a policy.
The rehabilitation was not sentiment. Li Shou had taken the throne by force from a ruler who had taken it by force, and he needed a charge to justify what he had done. The charge was that Li Qi had murdered the rightful sovereign. For the charge to hold, Li Ban had to have been the rightful sovereign. So Li Shou tried the case backwards: he established the victim and then convicted the killer. The same reasoning that made Li Ban an emperor made Li Shou a restorer rather than a usurper.
The fates of the three cousins belong together. Li Qi called Li Ban the Violent Heir; Li Shou called Li Qi the Secluded Duke; Li Shou called himself emperor and died in his bed. The names were not verdicts on character. They were the positions the survivors needed the dead to occupy.

5. What Four Months Leave

Two accounts survive, a local history of the southwest written after the fall by an official who had served the house, and a later dynastic chapter in the Book of Jin that reworked the same archive; they agree about the murder and disagree about the man. What they contain is short enough to list in a breath: three appointments, one refusal to send two cousins out of the capital, one omen and one failure to read it, one killing, one forged order and one deposition. No edict, no tax rate, no appointment of a provincial governor, no campaign, no building, no grant. The reign of Li Ban consists of the things that were done to him.
The thinness has causes, and they are worth naming, because they are not the ordinary accidents of transmission. The first is that he governed by not governing: the business of the state was in the hands of Li Shou and two ministers, and a decision taken by them would be recorded as theirs. The second is that the archive belonged to his murderers. For four years the men who killed him controlled the palace and the clerks, and the history of the reign was written from what they kept. The third is that his household was destroyed. His sons were killed, his mother was killed, his brother fled to the enemy, and a family with no survivors does not keep its papers. There was no one left with an interest in remembering what he had said in the mourning hall.
The two accounts also disagree about his character, and the disagreement is more useful than either portrait. The official chapter makes him modest, open to advice, strict with himself, generous with others and filial. The local history, written closer to the events by a man who had lived under the same government, adds a sentence the official chapter dropped: he was hasty, and his failing was hunting. That is not a portrait of a saint. It is a portrait of a young man with good manners and a horse, who was given a throne in the middle of a funeral and did not know what to do with it. The two accounts do not even agree on his age, and their figures are about a decade apart; no birth year is recorded, and none is used here.
There may be one physical trace. A tomb in the south of Chengdu, opened in the 1980s, produced bricks stamped with the twenty-fourth year of Yuheng and others from the Hanxing period that followed Li Shou's accession. Archaeologists have proposed that it might be Li Ban's, on the reasoning that the man who killed him would not have built him a tomb and the cousin who rehabilitated him might have. The identification rests on the bricks and the politics, not on an inscription. It is a reasonable guess and it remains a guess.
None of this is a complaint about the sources. A reign that leaves no edicts has told us something that a reign full of them could not. Four months in the mourning hall, with the government in other hands and the guard commanded by a dead brother, describes a monarchy in which the ruler was the only person who was not allowed to act.

6. One Heir and Four Armies

Li Xiong had settled who would sit on the throne. He had not settled who would stand around it.
At the moment of his death there were four men in the family with troops or clients. Li Yue held the garrison at Jiangyang. Li Qi had a thousand clients in the capital and a name. Li Shou held the regency and the southern army that had taken Ningzhou. Li Wu held the northern command at Fu. The heir held the coffin. The old king had spent thirty years building a state in which a following was the only real property, and then had given the throne to the one man in the family who owned none.
The rule he invoked made this worse rather than better. He had passed over his sons in the name of a debt to his brother, and a debt is a claim that can be argued about. His sons answered with a rule that could not be argued about at all: a son is a son. Once both propositions were in the air, every member of the family had a reason to prefer one of them and no member had a reason to accept the other.
The consequences run in a straight line. In 335 Li Ban's maternal uncle, Luo Yan, tried to put Li Ban's son on the throne and was killed, together with Li Ban's mother. In 338 Li Shou did to Li Qi what Li Yue had done to Li Ban, with more troops and better timing. In 343 Li Shou died. In 347 the state surrendered to a Jin army and its last ruler was taken east. Between the night in the mourning hall and the end there were thirteen years, four rulers and one act, repeated.
Li Wu, who had advised his brother to separate the two cousins and had been sent away for it, died in the service of Jin in the last of those years. He is the only one of the five brothers who did not die by the sword of his own family, and he died in the ranks of the army that ended it.
The house learned in one night that the throne could be taken from inside the family. It had thirteen years left, and it spent them proving that it had learned nothing else.