Home / Emperors / Sixteen Kingdoms
Duke Qiongdu of Cheng-Han
成汉邛都县公
Li Qi, ? – 338 · ruler of Cheng-Han · deposed as Duke of Qiongdu, posthumously Duke You
The tenth month of 334 opened on a new moon, and the hall where Li Xiong lay was dark. His nephew Li Ban, emperor since the sixth month, was keeping vigil at the coffin, as a son of the house was expected to do. Li Yue came in from Jiangyang, where he commanded the cavalry, and killed him at the coffin. Li Yue had spent the funeral arranging this with his younger brother Li Qi, the fourth son of the dead founder, and it was Li Qi who took the throne the next morning. The coup consisted of one man, one sword, and one unlit room.
Four years later the same thing happened to him, in the same city, with the same instruments: a kinsman's garrison, an order issued in an empress's name, and a morning in which nobody fought. He was deposed in the fourth month of 338 and was dead by the fifth. What makes the reign worth attending to is not the violence, which was ordinary in his family. It is that those four years used up a particular idea of why the Li house should rule at all. Li Xiong had held Shu for thirty years by being the man the refugee leaders of the six commanderies could agree on, and by paying his relatives in commands and revenue. Li Ban held it for four months on a reputation for filial piety. Li Qi held it because he had the palace and his brother had the cavalry. After him nobody in Chengdu could claim anything else, and the two men who followed him ruled the way he had ruled.
1. The Fourth Son
Li Qi was the fourth son of Li Xiong. His mother, Ran, was of low birth; he was raised by Li Xiong's wife, the empress Ren, and that arrangement gave him the standing of a wife's son without the birth. In that house a wife's son had a claim and a concubine's son did not, and the distinction would decide who could be emperor. His elder cousin Li Ban, the son of Li Xiong's brother Li Dang, was the man his father chose; Li Shou, the general at Fucheng, was his father's cousin and therefore his senior by one generation. The names are close in English and the relationships are not: Li Qi was Li Xiong's son, not Li Ban's.
The chapter's account of his youth is the only warm passage in it, and it describes a talent for patronage rather than for government. He was clever, fond of learning, able to write a polished piece while still young, free with money, and eager for retainers. Li Xiong, testing his sons, told them to gather followers by kindness and good faith; most of them reached a few hundred men, and Li Qi, the chapter says, reached more than a thousand. His recommendations were usually accepted, so the staff offices of the government filled with men who owed their posts to him. Read one way this is the portrait of a generous prince. Read another, it is the portrait of a faction, assembled years before it was needed, in the building where the appointments were written.
Li Xiong passed over his own sons to make Li Ban his heir, on the grounds of the young man's character and out of grief for his dead brother's line, and the sons took it as an insult. Li Yue, posted at Jiangyang with the cavalry, said it was unbearable. In the sixth month of 334 Li Xiong died, and Li Ban did what a mourning nephew was supposed to do: he stayed in the hall with the body and left the government to Li Shou and the old ministers. Li Wu, Li Ban's brother, saw what was coming and asked to have Li Yue sent back to his command and Li Qi posted far away at Jiameng. Li Ban refused, because his uncle was not yet buried, and sent Li Wu away instead. The court astronomer reported two white streaks across the sky and warned of a plot among close relatives. Nothing was done.
Li Ban was killed at the coffin in the tenth month. What followed was a piece of paperwork. A decree drawn up in the empress dowager Ren's name declared Li Ban unfit and deposed him; the assembly wanted Li Yue, and Li Yue declined in favour of Li Qi, on the grounds that Ren had raised him and that he had a name for ability. Li Qi took the throne the next day and changed the era. He had won nothing. He had been selected by men who could select someone else, and his claim rested on a name borrowed from a woman who had not been consulted.
He spent the first weeks making the selection final. Li Ban's brother Li Du was killed; another, Li Wu, was attacked at Fu and escaped across the Jin border, where the eastern court gave him a commandery. The pattern was set: the men who might contest the throne were removed, and the ones who escaped became the enemy's officers.
2. Four Years
The settlement of 334 looked generous and was not. Li Yue became chancellor and prince of Jianning. Li Shou was made grand commander, prince of Han, governor of Liang province and commandant of the eastern Qiang, and was sent to hold Fucheng. Li Qi's brothers Li Ba and Li Bao received the palace guard and the governorship of Wenshan. A cousin was posted to Jiangyang to replace Li Yue. Every office that mattered went to a man who had helped, or to a man who had to be watched, and usually to a man who was both. A new reign normally buys a year of goodwill with appointments like these. Li Qi bought nothing with them; he moved the pieces into the squares from which they could later move themselves.
The government he ran was small and personal. The chapter names the men who mattered: Jing Qian at the head of the secretariat, the ministers Yao Hua and Tian Bao, and the eunuch Xu Fu, who carried the emperor's errands. Tian Bao had once urged Li Xiong to make Li Qi the heir and was trusted far beyond his ability; the others were trusted for agreeing. Justice, appointment and punishment were settled by four or five men in the inner rooms, and the senior ministers were informed of the results. The chapter says that the framework of government went slack. It is the kind of sentence an official writes when he means that the paperwork still moved and no longer decided anything.
One case survives in any detail. Li Zai, assistant director of the secretariat and duke of Wuling, was accused of treason and died in prison. The accusation is the whole of the evidence; the record gives no charge, no witnesses and no trial. What such an entry preserves is not a crime but a method, by which a senior man is removed with a document and his office and household pass to others. Two of the emperor's brothers, Li Ba and Li Bao, then died of no illness, and the court said he had poisoned them. After that the chapter stops listing names and summarizes instead: many families destroyed, their women and goods taken into the palace, the roads reduced to eye contact, remonstrance treated as an offence. The annalist set two prodigies in the same paragraph, yellow fish falling in the palace yard and pigs and dogs coupling there, because he had nothing else to set beside the executions. Four years produced no law, no granary, no road and no building. A reign that leaves no public work leaves its historian the weather and the dead.
The one campaign was in the north. A Jin general, Sima Xun, had posted himself at Hanzhong, and Li Qi sent Li Shou against him; the chapter records that the place was taken, officials installed and a garrison left at Nanzheng, and records nothing else about the war, which is probably the whole of it. Toward the Di and Qiang villages of the western mountains there is no campaign at all, only two titles: the commandant of the eastern Qiang went with Li Shou's princedom, and the governorship of Wenshan went to his brother. That is the entire military record of the reign, one captured city and two appointments.
The rest of the four years is the story of a man watching a general. Li Shou had the best reputation in the state and a garrison of his own, and the court feared him from the first year. Xu Fu was sent north repeatedly to look at him. Li Shou answered by staying at his post and saying that the frontier could not be left undefended, and the excuse was accepted because it was true. When a senior kinsman accused Li Shou of plotting and asked for his death, Li Qi refused, because he still needed a general to chase Li Wu. Li Shou then warned Li Wu and opened the road for him to escape, which was treason in all but name; nothing was done, because the frontier needed a general more than the court needed an arrest.
The end of the arrangement was a single killing. Li Qi had Li You poisoned, Li Shou's foster-brother and a general of the north, and the chapter is explicit that this death changed the calculation. It was no longer a question of careers. Li Qi, Li Yue and his three confidants then agreed to attack Li Shou, and the plan was to burn the market bridge and raise troops while the city was cut in two. Li Shou, hearing of it, forged a letter from his brother-in-law saying that the emperor meant to destroy him, and showed it to his officers. They believed it. That is the one fact in the story that needs explaining, and it explains itself: they had watched him kill his brothers.
This is how suspicion manufactures the enemy it fears. Each measure was reasonable on its own. A general with a good reputation is watched; a watched general stops coming to court; a general who stops coming to court looks like a rebel; a general who looks like a rebel is watched more closely, and is told, by the watching, that he will be killed. Li Qi's precautions narrowed Li Shou's choices until one remained. The chapter says Li Shou was afraid. It does not say he wanted the throne, and by the time he marched the distinction had stopped mattering to anyone.
3. One Morning
In the fourth month of 338 Li Shou's soldiers were at the palace gate. What stood between the gate and the throne was the palace guard, and the guard had been paid, posted and promoted by the same court that was now asking it to fight. Li Qi's brother Li Yue was killed, and with him Jing Qian, Tian Bao, Yao Hua and Xu Fu. A decree issued under the seal of the empress dowager Ren then deposed Li Qi as Duke of Qiongdu, a county dukedom, and confined him to a separate palace.
The instrument was the one that had made him. In 334 a decree under her seal had unmade Li Ban; in 338 the same seal unmade Li Qi, with the same formula, the repair of a succession rather than the seizure of one. She had raised him and had been made to legitimize him; she was now made to abolish him. He never controlled the one thing his enemies needed, which was a way of making force look like law.
He lived a few weeks. The chapter gives him one line of speech, and it is about the smallness of the word: that the master of the world had come down to a county duke, and that he would rather be dead. In the fifth month he hanged himself. After him, Li Xiong's remaining sons were killed, and the family that had held the throne for a generation was reduced to the branch that had marched.
He had done it in a night and it was done to him in a morning. The difference between 334 and 338 is not moral but technical. The second coup was cheaper than the first, because the first had already established that a coup was a way of changing governments, and because it had left a general in a frontier garrison with ten thousand men and a reason.
4. The Names
Li Qi had one thing to give the dead, and he gave it in the first days: Li Ban, who had reigned four months, was declared a crown prince and given the epithet Li, which means cruel or perverse. The point of the title was its rank. An emperor's name would have conceded that the throne had been filled when Li Qi took it; a crown prince's name said that the succession had never happened, and that the man who corrected it had restored the family's order. It cost one word and no soldiers.
Four years later the word was taken back. Li Shou, having deposed Li Qi, promoted the dead crown prince to emperor and gave him the name Ai. Both names for Li Ban were issued by men who had just killed a sovereign, and each was the receipt for a coup: the first said that Li Ban had never ruled, the second that he had ruled and been murdered, and only the second made the murder a crime. The name Li Qi received was smaller than either.
He was given the name You and buried with the rites of a prince and a carriage of nine tassels. The word can mean dark, or hidden, or shut away, and the man who chose it had shut him in a separate palace. A name settles a claim, and a small name settles it more cheaply.
A deposed emperor is a problem for every later list. In the tables he is entered sometimes as Duke of Qiongdu and sometimes as Duke You; the only imperial thing about the entry is the four years, and even those are counted differently. Yuheng begins in 335 in the chronological tables and at his accession in the chapter. The chapter dates his death to 337 and gives him three years on the throne; the chronicle puts the death in the fifth month of 338. A commentator in the thirteenth century noticed the gap and left it where it was. A reign that cannot agree on its own length has already been filed as an incident.
5. What Was Left
The Li house had ruled Shu on three different claims, and Li Qi spent the third one. Li Xiong's claim had been the hardest to make and the most solid once made: he was the man the refugee leaders of the six commanderies had chosen, he had kept taxes low for thirty years, and he had bound the family to the state by giving his kinsmen commands, revenues and troops. That arrangement was a federation of cousins with a respected man at the centre. It worked while the centre was respected. It made every cousin a potential commander, and every commander a potential claimant.
Li Ban's claim had been the softest: a reputation for filial piety, and the old men's preference for the dead brother's line. It was a claim that required belief and offered nobody a reason to fight. Li Qi's claim was the hardest of the three to argue and the easiest to enforce, since it consisted of the palace guard and a brother's cavalry. Once that was enough, it was enough for everyone. The geography of the state did the rest: with commands at Jiangyang, Fu and Jiameng, any kinsman with a garrison was a candidate, and the palace guard was one more command among the commands.
The thinness of the record is evidence of two things. The annalists kept prodigies and punishments, which is what a court diary records when nothing else is happening; and the material passed through the hands of the family that replaced him. Li Shou's court had every reason to remember Li Qi as a poisoner of brothers and a killer of ministers, and the story reached the later histories through that filter. It is not necessary to doubt the killings to notice that the man who benefited from the portrait supervised its copying.
He is also the ruler who made the throne of Shu ordinary. Before 334 the office had been held by the founder and by an heir chosen for his character; the family could tell itself a story about why it ruled. After 338 the office was held by whoever had the gate, and the story was no longer available. Li Shou spent his five years trying to buy a substitute for it and did not find one. His son inherited the habit of killing ministers and, in 347, gave up the province to a Jin general.
The state outlived Li Qi by nine years. The discovery he made in the tenth month of 334 outlived the state, and it was not his discovery alone: everyone in Chengdu learned it at the same time, in the same dark hall. A throne that can be taken by one man with a sword and a brother at the door will be taken again, and the only question for the next claimant is whether the door will be opened from the inside.